How Criminal Defense Lawyers in San Bernardino Handle Murder Cases

How Criminal Defense Lawyers in San Bernardino Handle Murder Cases
By: Tammy Higgins | October 5, 2026 | 

Murder defense in San Bernardino County is decided far more often in the year before trial than in the courtroom itself. The work is the preliminary examination, the forensic review, the independent investigation, and the fight over degree and malice, all of which happen while the case is still being shaped.

A trusted San Bernardino criminal defense firm takes these cases, and attorney Tammy Higgins spent 16 years as a San Bernardino County public defender specializing in homicide before entering private practice, with more than 100 jury trials behind her including homicide cases tried to verdict. Families calling about a PC 187 charge usually want to know whether anything can be done, and the honest answer starts with what the prosecution actually has to prove.

What the Prosecution Has to Prove Under PC 187

Murder under Penal Code 187 is the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought, and malice is where most of the real argument lives. Express malice means an intent to kill. Implied malice means acting with conscious disregard for human life, knowing the conduct was dangerous to it, which reaches conduct where no one intended a death at all.

First degree murder requires more. The killing must be willful, deliberate, and premeditated, or committed by one of the specific means the statute enumerates, or committed during one of the felonies that trigger the felony murder rule as narrowed by SB 1437. Everything else that carries malice is second degree. The gap between those two findings is ten years of minimum exposure, and a defense that concentrates on premeditation rather than on the killing itself is frequently working on the most contestable element in the case.

The Preliminary Examination as the First Real Test

Felony homicide cases proceed to a preliminary examination where the prosecution must show sufficient evidence to send the case to trial. The standard is lower than the trial standard, so the hearing rarely ends the case outright. Treating it as a formality is still a mistake.

The preliminary examination is where the defense first cross-examines the prosecution's witnesses under oath, months or years before trial, while their accounts are less rehearsed and before they have been prepared by the trial team. Testimony given at that hearing is locked in, and a witness who shifts later can be confronted with it. The hearing also reveals the shape of the case: which witnesses the office is relying on, how the forensic evidence is being presented, and where the theory has soft ground. Counts are sometimes dismissed at this stage and charges sometimes reduced. Results vary by case. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results.

Families weighing what to do after a homicide arrest should get the case reviewed before the preliminary examination rather than after it. Testimony locked in at that hearing cannot be unlocked later. That same urgency carries through to the end of the case too; knowing how to appeal a criminal conviction and its strict filing deadlines is something families often wish they'd learned before the verdict rather than after.

Has someone you love just been arrested on a homicide charge? Call 949-226-7602 before the preliminary examination, and we'll review the case while there is still time to shape it.

Degree, Malice and Where Cases Get Narrowed

Homicide in California is a ladder rather than a single charge, and much of the defense work is about which rung the facts actually reach.

ChargeMental state requiredExposure
First degree murder, PC 187Malice with premeditation and deliberation25 years to life
Second-degree murder, PC 187Malice without premeditation15 years to life
Voluntary manslaughter, PC 192(a)Heat of passion or imperfect self-defense3, 6, or 11 years
Involuntary manslaughter, PC 192(b)Criminal negligence, no malice2, 3, or 4 years
Attempted murder, PC 664/187Specific intent to kill5, 7 or 9 years, or life if premeditated

Two doctrines move cases down that ladder. Imperfect self-defense applies where the defendant genuinely believed deadly force was necessary but the belief was unreasonable, and it reduces murder to voluntary manslaughter rather than producing an acquittal.

Heat of passion applies where legally adequate provocation preceded the killing and a reasonable person would not yet have cooled. Perfect self-defense, where the belief was both genuine and reasonable, is a complete defense, and the distinctions between manslaughter and the two degrees of murder decide which of these is even available.

Building the Defense Investigation

The prosecution arrives with an investigation already completed by a law enforcement agency. The defense has to build its own, and in a homicide case that means retaining investigators and experts rather than relying on the discovery the state provides. Capacity is the practical difference here, and it is the heart of the choice between private counsel and a court-appointed public defender.

The work covers ground the police file often does not. Witnesses are located and interviewed independently, because a person who spoke briefly to a detective at a chaotic scene frequently says something different months later in a calm conversation. Scene reconstruction tests whether the sequence the prosecution describes is physically consistent with the distances, sightlines, and lighting. Forensic materials get reviewed by independent analysts, since DNA mixture interpretation, firearms comparison, and time-of-death estimates all carry assumptions that deserve testing.

Social media, phone records and surveillance footage have short retention windows, which is why preservation requests go out early rather than when trial approaches. Under Penal Code 987.9, a defendant facing life exposure who cannot afford these resources may apply confidentially to the court for funding.

Trial, and the Post-Conviction Door That Stays Open

Homicide trials run days or weeks. The prosecution presents first and carries the burden on every element beyond a reasonable doubt; the defense cross-examines each witness and may present its own case, and the verdict must be unanimous. Focused homicide defense work in San Bernardino County is built around that reality rather than around settling, because prosecutors calibrate what they are willing to offer against who is on the other side of the table.

A conviction does not close the file. Direct appeal challenges legal error in the trial record. Habeas corpus raises what the record cannot show, including ineffective assistance and undisclosed evidence. Petitions under PC 1172.6 reach people convicted under theories of liability that SB 1437 and SB 775 have since narrowed, which has produced relief for defendants who were never the actual killer.

Resentencing under AB 600 permits a court to recall a sentence that is no longer proportional under current law, and Racial Justice Act petitions under AB 256 apply retroactively where race, ethnicity or national origin was a factor in charging, trial, or sentencing. Families whose relative was convicted fifteen years ago frequently have options today that did not exist at sentencing.

A murder charge is a sequence of decisions, and the earliest ones carry the most weight. Call 949-226-7602 for a free confidential consultation, available 24/7, and we'll tell you what the prosecution actually has to prove in your case.

Related Topics:

What sets us apart
Why Choose
socal criminal
defense Lawyer
Expertise and Experience
Personalized Legal Strategies
Transparent Communication
Advocates for Your Rights
Responsive and Accessible
Transparent and Upront Pricing
SCHEDULE A FREE CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION
fill out the form

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Full Name*
Required Fields *
chevron-down